Are Nirvana and Moksha two paths to the same freedom?
I have long believed that the Nirvana of Zen Buddhism and the Moksha of Advaita Vedanta point toward the same ultimate freedom.
At first, this sounds contradictory. Buddhism teaches anātman (no-self), while Advaita teaches Ātman (the true Self).
But perhaps the difference begins with what each tradition means by the word self.
What Is the Self We Must Let Go Of?
Advaita distinguishes the true Self from our ordinary psychological identity.
The mind (manas), intellect (buddhi), ego (ahaṅkāra), and memory (chitta) are all part of our changing inner experience.
The Nirvāṇa Ṣaṭkam, traditionally attributed to Adi Shankaracharya, begins:
Mano-buddhy-ahaṅkāra-cittāni nāham.
I am not the mind, intellect, ego, or memory.
This is where I see a deep connection with Zen.
What Zen asks us to stop identifying with closely resembles what Advaita also tells us we are not: our thoughts, personality, memories, and sense of being a separate individual.
Of course, classical Buddhism goes further and does not affirm an eternal Ātman as Advaita does. Their philosophical differences are real.
Yet their practices reveal a remarkable common ground.
Krishna’s Dhyāna and Zen’s Zazen
In Chapter 6 of the Bhagavad Gita, Krishna describes the practice of meditation.
For the full method and its purpose, read The Importance and Method of Dhyāna in the Bhagavad Gita.
Verse 6.25 says:
Ātma-saṃsthaṃ manaḥ kṛtvā na kiñcid api cintayet.
Establish the mind in the Self, and think of nothing else.
In the next verse, Krishna instructs us to bring the mind back whenever it wanders.
Now consider Zen’s practice of zazen.
We sit quietly, maintain a steady posture, allow thoughts to arise and pass, and return whenever the mind becomes distracted.
The resemblance is striking.
Krishna teaches us to settle the restless mind in the Self. Zen teaches us to sit without clinging to thoughts or a separate identity.
The methods are not exactly identical. Zazen, particularly Dōgen’s shikantaza, is not simply a concentration exercise directed toward a metaphysical Self.
But both practices help us move beyond the restless activity of the ego.
Dōgen beautifully expresses this:
To study the self is to forget the self.
Perhaps this is another way of approaching what Advaita calls neti, neti — not this, not this.
Emptiness Is Not Nothingness
Zen’s śūnyatā, or emptiness, is often misunderstood as the absence of everything.
But emptiness does not mean that nothing exists. It means that nothing possesses an independent, permanent nature.
Advaita approaches reality differently. Through neti, neti, we reject false identification with everything changing, ultimately recognizing Ātman.
One tradition emphasizes emptiness of independent self-nature. The other affirms the reality of the Self beyond the body and mind.
I see them almost like yin and yang: different, yet potentially complementary ways of loosening our attachment to the separate ego.
In nothingness, there is isness.
This is my own way of expressing what I sense at the meeting point of these traditions.
Nirvana and Moksha: One Freedom?
Interestingly, Krishna uses the word nirvāṇa in Bhagavad Gita 6.15 while describing the supreme peace attained through meditation.
This does not mean that Krishna’s teaching and Buddhist Nirvana are doctrinally identical. But the shared language of liberation is fascinating.
Zen speaks of freedom from clinging and ignorance.
Advaita speaks of freedom through Self-knowledge.
Both challenge our identification with the ego, our attachment to desires, and our habit of looking for lasting happiness outside ourselves.
I do not claim that their philosophical definitions are identical.
But I believe Nirvana and Moksha may point toward the same freedom, approached and understood differently.
Zen reminds me to let go of the self I imagine myself to be.
Advaita reminds me to inquire into what I truly am.
And perhaps the most important insight is not found in arguing about the words self and no-self, but in the silence that opens when the ego no longer occupies the centre of our lives.
In nothingness, there is isness.
And perhaps, in that isness, there is freedom.
— Naveen Niverthy · Think Better & Thrive
Leave a Reply